Do I have to go to mediation?
If you can reach an agreement yourselves, you do not need to go to mediation. If you are struggling to do this, mediation can be helpful. If one of you decides to ask the family court for a formal decision, the court will expect you to try mediation or another type of help to resolve your dispute before it deals with the problem and makes a decision for you. This is because the government thinks, with good reason, that it is usually better that you decide these things between yourselves if you can, rather than the court telling everyone what to do.
So, if you are considering going to court you need to have had an introductory meeting about mediation first. These are called Mediation Information and Assessment Meetings or MIAMs for short. You need to attend one of these meetings unless you have an agreement already written down that you want made into an order by the court (called a consent order), or if you can show you are exempt.
I like the idea of mediation, but I’m not sure I can face the idea of seeing my ex again and again.
Many people feel like this. Having to see and speak to your ex is both a challenge and also, potentially, can be a positive side-effect of mediation. Many people find it enables them to communicate with their ex again, which if you have children together can only be a good thing.
If you are dead set against it, many mediators can see you separately and offer mediation where you and your ex sit in separate rooms, or mediate by video call, in separate virtual ‘rooms’. This is sometimes called ‘shuttle mediation’. Your other option is to use a solicitor to negotiate on your behalf. This can be more expensive but, particularly if there are issues of abuse, it can feel safer to have an expert on your side, making your case for you. You can find a good family law solicitor who believes in a constructive, non-confrontational approach on the Resolution website.
If you have children, it is worth thinking about how you’re going to manage in the years ahead and what it will feel like dealing with your ex when you no longer have your solicitor involved. Using a mediator can be a useful way of reducing conflict with your ex in a safe and controlled way, which could make it easier for you in the future.
We need to sort out arrangements for our children who are now 12 and 15. Can or should they be involved in the mediation?
The mediator should explain, at the first meeting, that children over the age of 10 should get the chance to speak with a mediator as part of the wider process. This is to help both parents take into account their views when working towards a future plan that involves them. Younger children can also be involved, if both parents agree.
If you, the children and the mediator agree, then the children can speak to the mediator themselves. Some mediators are specially trained to talk to children (you can search for them by ticking the bottom box on the Family Mediation Council search tool). It can be helpful for the children to be involved about the issues that affect them such as where they will live, which parent they live with, and how often they will see their other parent. The weight given to the children’s thoughts will depend on how old they are and how mature they are.
You can read more about child inclusive mediation, where children and young people are given a voice by a mediator on the Family Mediation Council website.
I would not trust my ex to actually do what she’s agreed to do. Would I be better off sorting it out another way?
The costs involved will depend on how complicated the agreement is and if you can find a solicitor who will offer you a fixed fee for sorting it all out, or if you have to pay an hourly rate. There will also be a court fee to pay.
If you think your ex will lie about their finances you might want to consider using a solicitor instead of, or alongside, mediation.
You cannot usually get agreements about the children made into a court order in the same way. This is because the law says that the court should only make orders about children if it would be better for the children than making no order. But, as court orders about children are hard to enforce anyway especially if the children are older than around 12 years old, coming to agreements that work for everyone, and especially for the children, is is probably still your best option.
I am worried about having to make my case myself. Can my solicitor come to the mediation sessions with me?
Usually your solicitor does not go to mediation with you. You can get advice from a solicitor between sessions to check that the agreements you are coming to are fair. The mediator will ensure that you are properly heard and that your case is understood by everyone present.
However, there are other options. One is hybrid mediation, also known as intergrated mediation, and another is collaborative practice.
Hybrid mediation, or intergrated mediation, is where you go to mediation with your solicitor, who gives you legal advice right there and then, rather than in between or after your mediation sessions. It is usual for your ex to have a solicitor there too or available via video call, but it is not compulsory. This approach can speed the whole process up and so ultimately can save money, if you can afford to have a solicitor there in the first place. Other professionals can be involved in the same way – such as pensions advisors or financial advisers..
Collaborative practice involves you and your solicitor meeting with your ex and their solicitor to come to an agreement. If you can afford it (and it is quite expensive), that might be a better choice for you. You can find a collaborative lawyer on the Resolution website.
My ex is very persuasive and charming. How can I be sure that the mediator will not be biased?
Mediators are trained to be unbiased. They do not take sides or decide who they like best. They make sure that both of you have the opportunity to say what you need to say and help you reach an agreed plan for the future. When you have the first meeting before you start mediation talk to the mediator about any concerns so that you can ensure you have complete confidence in their ability to remain impartial.
Is mediation cheaper than using a solicitor to negotiate for me?
If you are entitled to legal aid, then mediation will be free for you, including a small amount of legal advice alongside it – if you are able to find a legal aid solicitor who offers this service. In most cases, legal aid is not available for solicitors to represent you and sort things out for you anymore, so you would have to pay for a solicitor to negotiate for you.
If you are not entitled to legal aid, it is usually a lot cheaper to mediate rather than use a solicitor to negotiate everything for you. If you are making arrangements for your children, you can get a £500 mediation voucher per separated couple, to help pay for your mediation sessions.
How much mediation will cost depends on whether you are able to come to an agreement or not, and if so, how quickly. If you can agree on some issues fairly quickly and narrow the points of disagreement you will have saved money. This is because mediators usually charge less than solicitors and even if their fees are similar, mediation usually helps you get to an agreement more quickly than if you just use solicitors.
If you cannot come to an agreement or have only agreed on some things, you have to pay for the mediation and for whatever solicitor and court fees it takes to get the rest of the matter sorted.
I’ve been given legal advice that says what I should get, but my ex is never going to agree to that. Is there any point in going to mediation?
Yes. It is very normal in a time of relationship breakdown to see the problems as too big to make mediation worthwhile, but the mediator is an expert in problem-solving and resolving conflict.
Also, bear in mind that the advice you have been given by a solicitor was probably that they thought you could argue for ‘this’, not that a judge would definitely award you ‘this’ or that such an award is the only thing that would be fair. A different solicitor may well give your ex different advice about what a court might order.
If you can come to an agreement (through mediation or another method) you will save money on court fees, solicitors fees if you have a solicitor, save yourself a considerable amount of stress, and usually save yourselves from further damaging your relationship – which has got to be good, especially if you have children together.
Do remember though, for your agreement to be legally binding you need to ask the court to turn it into a court order. There will be costs involved in this process but using mediation to reach an agreement and then getting legal advice on formalising it is likely to be much cheaper than paying a solicitor to negotiate each and every thing you disagree on.
I don’t think we’re ever going to agree. Going straight to court just seems quicker and easier.
Sometimes people have the idea that going to court is what you should do. But if you want to go to court over a family problem, you must show the court that you have met with a mediator first and considered mediation or you that have tried some other type of help to come to an agreement, known by the court as non-court dispute resolution.
This expectation applies to cases about children and your money and property when you divorce unless there are serious concerns about the children’s safety or allegations of domestic abuse. In practice very few cases end up in a court hearing, and for good reason. You have to wait a long time for court date, it can then take months for the case to finish. If you use a solicitor their fees can build up very quickly to thousands of pounds so it is neither quick nor easy. Also it is important to know that, if you do go to court, the judge will expect you to compromise as much as possible, just like in mediation and may even pause the case to ask you to try mediation or some other service to help you sort out your disagreement.